| | Mary Elizabeth Butler 1850–1897 Robert Emmet Sheldon 1845–1917 | | |
| | Courtland Philip Livingston Butler 1813–1891 Elizabeth Slade Pierce 1822–1901 | | |
| | Judith Livingston 1785–1858 Samuel Herrick Butler 1785–1851 | | |
| | Gilbert James Livingston 1758–1833 | | |
| | | | | | Henry Vanderburgh 1716–1787 |
|
|
